Best Tv Blog

Wednesday, April 26, 2006

Freshmen Analysis

Over the next few days we are going to be analyzing how the networks did with their respective new series.

Staring with Fall 2005:

Fox: 3 of their 7 new show will be keepers. Prison Break and Bones are 2nd-tier hits, although PB's staying power is highly questionable. The War at Home is respectable, as the # 4 comedy show. Head Cases was dead on arrival, Reunion didnt work out, Killer Instinct was a disaster, and Kitchen Confidential was worse than infamously-ratings starved Arrested Development.

Analysis: 3 outta 7 isn't terrible, buit none were hits. The 4 cancelled shows combied for under 20 episodes.

NBC: At least Fox showed originality with their cancelled shows, NBC's lasted longer but were all lame from day 1. Inconcievable was a joke, Three Wishes was a poor Extreme makeover wannabe. E-Ring still having a shot at making the Fall sched. only shows how weak the Peacock is. Surface was the worst of the 3 Lost-esque shows and stands little hope of a 2nd season. Martha Stewart's Apprentice made the Trump version look like 24 by comparison. My Name is Earl is a solid # 2 comedy, but it didn't come close to saving the network like was speculated. Anyway, Earl would've needed to be American-Idol big to have salvaged this disaster cass for NBC.